Jake,
You had to go a long ways to find us.... we're used to it. One of the most fun quirks of owning an X is that famous question "what is that?"..... never ends.
The jennie you are asking about, is pretty much next door to me in this region, and I have no idea if it has sold or not, as I don't even know the owner...... and as long as our story has continued, there are fewer and fewer owners that we don't know.... but the stray X's still straggle in here and there.
I'm currently updating a jennie (1973) for Chad Arndt out of St. Jo Mizzou.... he got it for a little bit under market price, with some updates and some unknowns. Pretty sure its never been plated, and it has only 1,700 miles on it. ....
Yes there were a lot of negative comments about our bikes in the day..... and I believe as many positive though too. when it all boils down, to me, with the small production number produced, they are in a sense, prototypes. Since the factory doors shut, a large portion of critics changed their story over to: "who'd want to buy a orphan bike, you can't get parts for.......?" Amazingly, parts really haven't been an issue yet. But as they age, I'm sure we'll have to cross that creek....
Prices on our beauties are currently pretty cheap actually... You can buy/find nice X's with all updates done and fair mileage in the 6-7 range. Exceptions will be up and down this area..
Watch ebay, craigs list, and cycle trader... ebay has the most. AND I've found if a person just asks around within the community, there are some dandys here and there. You may pay a little more, but you probably will know more about what you are getting, and being we are such a small community, most of us don't want to get burned, or burn anyone within ourselves. I'd recommend to stay away from dealer sales, unless you know everything about that bike, as most dealers have no idea what they are talking about when it concerns X's....
Very hard to compare, your Yamaha to an X. Power ban will be different (a pleasant different), ride will be much more comfortable (you be sitting in the bike, not on it), long distant rides will be more tolerable, short runs will be fun (but much more heavy), And looks outstanding (sorry, I'm bias).
Front fender is a "love it, or hate it" thing.... and unfortunately it is usually the first impression when walking up on one in the wild (lol). Its hard to hold someones attention to the other marvelous plus's of our bikes, if they have snubbed the front fender right off the get go. ...
Best buddy is a hard core HD guy.... He loves our X's, but won't buy one, because he hates that front fender..... well, that, and his HD is a full dresser, with all the toys....